Skip to content

Fetishizing Phones

Wed, 16 Mar 2016, 08:12 PM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

Obama was in town the other day for the annual rite of the techno-hip. In keeping with my arm-chair, marginally-informed analyses of the last few days, I have some comments about a comment he made about the FBI’s effort to force Apple to fabricate a security backdoor.

Our President said, “We can’t fetishize our phones above other values.”

I’ve sat on that statement for several days. And now, I wish to try out that same reasoning in some different circumstances, just to see how the analytical technique holds up…

We can’t fetishize our banks above other values.

We can’t fetishize guns above other values.

We can’t fetishize the right to a jury of your peers above other values.

We can’t fetishize the right to vote above other values.

We can’t fetishize the right to remain silent above other values.

Do any of these statements make sense? No, they don’t.

This, in my humble opinion was simply an effort to trivialize the issue. To short-circuit informed thought. To radiate a false aura of balance. To play on fear. And to smear anyone who believes in encryption as a fetishist.

For what it’s worth, this page by Bruce Schneier has some pointers to non-arm-chair analyses of the same issue, and this article by Susan Crawford bluntly summarizes why the law is clear on this topic.

Fallen Iris

Wed, 16 Mar 2016, 06:14 PM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

“If I did that, I would have been in trouble,” Trudy said.

I just had taken a step on our garden path and inadvertently pushed an Iris stalk aside, breaking it off the plant. She was right, although I remained silent to hide my shame. I picked up the stalk and and stood there for a moment and then pointed to it.

“Look,” I said quietly. “There was another blossom coming in a couple days.”

“I would have so been in trouble,” she said.

I tossed the stalk into the messy place where the Spiny Lizards and Stag Beetles certainly roam on hot days, a good place for the stalk to decay, I thought.

That was a few days ago.

Today, as I walked around the yard after the commute home, admiring Texas spring in full bloom, I spotted that stalk. It had not begun to decay, far from it. Instead, that nascent bud that was going to open in a couple days had done so. And there, lying on the ground in the messy place, was an Iris blossom in full bloom: purple and orange, lost among the fallen leaves and Oak pollen tassels and sticks and logs that assemble there. 

I can no longer hide my shame. The flower has called me out.

En Garde

Tue, 15 Mar 2016, 09:48 PM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

Before I leave, there was this:

Anti Trust

Tue, 15 Mar 2016, 09:20 PM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

There’s a good (long form) article in the Washington monthly by Brian Feldman that talks about the decades-long decline of St. Louis and how much of it can be attributed to the fact that our political system has turned its back on the kind of anti-trust law that I was taught in junior high when I learned of the break up of ITT. The article is full of concrete examples of law after law that were relegated to dusty shelves as Democrats and Republicans alike let loose the furies of mergers and acquisitions that exploded in the 1980s and continue to this day. (Can you say, “Too big to fail”?)

I have a thought about this. Two thoughts, actually.

Thought number 1: Look ma! I read a long-form article. Me, Mr Short-Attention-Span.

Thought number 2: Robert Bork.

I am not a student of this, but I remember hearing a few years ago about how over his career, Bork embarked on (among other things, I assume) a project to rewrite the law surrounding anti-trust. As I recall it, he kept at it year after year, slowly crafting a new legal framework, slowly building an edifice that rejected the kinds of protections they taught in my 7th grade class. I half-expected to see mention of Bork’s role in the St. Louis decline in Feldman’s article.

I probably have some/many of the details wrong, but you don’t have to search far to find pieces of that story. For example, here on Wikipedia, where his book, The Antitrust Paradox, is discussed. Or read this Washington Post article which discusses Bork’s anti-trust legacy.

So my second thought is this: The essence of his framework was to elevate consumer welfare above all else. That anything goes as long as a bag of chips is cheap. Nothing is of value other than the prices paid by consumers. (Maybe I have it wrong. But that’s my grok-age of his framework.) And so, that brings us back to St. Louis: how does the steady and significant decline of a city measure in Bork’s economic calculus? Is that not a cost worthy of consideration?

Oh. And I have a corollary thought about Bork. It’s not a new one: … OMG, did we dodge a bullet.

The Sound of the Story

Tue, 15 Mar 2016, 06:05 AM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

NPR’s Renee Montagne was interviewing federal EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy this morning when I got out of the shower. It was a good story that went on for seven minutes. They were discussing Flint. I didn’t hear most of it, but when asked when the water would be safe to drink again, I did hear McCarthy say this, 

“The good news is that we did testing on the water filters and indeed the water filters do work very, very well even when the lead in the system is high.”

Now I don’t have any particular view on the role of EPA in this whole thing. I confess I don’t know enough about what they did or didn’t do. It is indeed good news that filters can remove lead from that water. And as part of that answer, McCarthy did concede that “it’s going to be a long time before people are comfortable drinking that water.” So it’s not really fair of me to launch into her or her agency, as I’d be more than happy to do to Snyder and his administration. And to her credit, the administrator did unambiguously say, in response to a question about the racial implications of the problem in Flint, “There is no question that this is an environmental justice issue.” Still, I do have a complaint about the report (which might come as no surprise to you)…

In response to a comment like this from the bureaucrats, be they from DC or East Lansing, it’s beyond me why reporters just let that kind of comment go. It’s institutional happy talk (true or false) that amounts to “Nothing to look at here, anymore. Move along.” In my not so humble opinion, any reporter who gets that sort of response from a top level official seeking to assuage concerns about some disaster should immediately ask this followup question.

“Did you drink the water, when you were there? Would you drink it and shower in it if you lived there?”

I don’t know if the good Governor Snyder’s appointed Flint city manager has a family or has kids, and I frankly don’t care to look it up in that browser window over there, but if he does I’d like to know, “Has he moved his family to Flint? Are they drinking our of bottles or from taps with these filters that (good news tells us) are working?” 

I suspect I know how they’d both answer those questions. They’d make the story sound just a tad different, wouldn’t they?

In Front of the Keyboard

Sun, 13 Mar 2016, 08:54 AM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

“Dude, you’re on a roll today.”

Here’s that guy again. He shows up from time to time to lob shots at this blog. I’m not sure what his objective is most of the time. I’m not quite sure how to respond. (To be honest, I’m not sure he even exists and isn’t instead just a voice inside my head, but we won’t go there.)

“You got nothing better to do on a weekend than sit in front of your keyboard?”

“Patience my friend. There is digging to do, and you’re free to pick up that mattock and help.”

“Wh…what are you talking about?”

“That’s ok. We won’t get started for a while. In the meantime, here’s some purple for my caretaker and companion, Chachi Bette, who recently returned from an all-too-brief sojourn down here and has now returned to the frigid land of snow-encrusted driveways.”

“But hey my friend, it’s glorious outside. The sky is blue. The sun is shining. The Mockingbirds and Cardinals and Wrens are singing. And as you have evidently noticed, the flowers are blooming. So we’ll wait for you in the backyard with the mattock and a couple shovels while this picture uploads. Join us, because this is indeed no day to be stuck in front of the keyboard! And because there is honestly no better way to celebrate a day like this than by digging in the dirt! We’ll see you in a few minutes.”

Jenny’s Birthday

Sun, 13 Mar 2016, 08:32 AM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

“I’m texting, now!” she announced, including a photo of yellow-blossomed Daffodils from their front yard.

Yesterday was her birthday. She had to tell me, instead of the other way around. And she had to text me a photo of flowers.

So even though it’s a day late, and even though we don’t have Daffodils here, and even though our blooming plants look a little wild, and even though the Cone Flowers are just hitting their stride, here are some blossoms for you, Jenny.

Happy Birthday!

Lizards

Sun, 13 Mar 2016, 08:22 AM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

I’ve told you about that Green Anole lizard, the one who has lived in the Agave near the driveway for several years. What I haven’t told you is that he is not alone.

On sunny days like yesterday, he can be found sitting on one of his back patios warming his cold-blooded bones.

And on those same sunny days, his cousin, whom I have not mentioned before and who has lived in the Boxwood for several years, can be found on his patio.

Any sunny day now the Texas Spiny Lizard will show up. He lives in the cluster of Turk’s Cap growing beside the Ash tree. He is not as taken with sunbathing as these two are, but on a good day, we can find him on his patio, a pile of dead wood at the base of the tree. We’ll keep our eyes peeled.

Where Eggs Come From

Thu, 10 Mar 2016, 07:53 AM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

So there I am, in the shower singing a song about a porcupine. I can see you hiiiiding in that Norrrrvay Pine… Just as I step out to dry off, the fair and industrious Trudy walks in. She is about to cook breakfast and has an uncracked egg cupped in her hands.

“Hey…” she says. “This is what we get when we get farm-fresh eggs.”

I look down at the egg. It is brown and small and… Well, I have to do a double-take. The egg has a tupée of sorts, tiny gray feathers stuck to the outside of the shell.

“Now we know!” she says with a broad smile on her face, holding the egg up and waving it about. “Eggs come from laying hens!”

 

Cleaning up Sticks

Tue, 8 Mar 2016, 07:30 AM (-06:00) Creative Commons License

I come by it honestly, this business of picking up sticks. My grandmother did it. We all do it. Although I confess that when I do it here, I’m not collecting kindling for the fireplace.

Anyway, there were sticks on the ground this morning. It must have been a windy day, and the Ash tree has been on its last legs for some time now, and I was picking up Ash twigs that had fallen on the sidewalk and french drain. 

And into the agave. An ash stick had fallen into the agave and was wanting to be cleaned up. So I leaned over the top of the agave and looked in, because you see I know that there is a lizard who lives in there — has for years. But it was cold this morning, so I figured he had retired to the nether apartments to stay warm. And based on that belief, I slowly reached in to clean out that stick.

I was wrong. He was there. As I reached in, he poked his face around the corner of the central agave spike with an alarmed look on his face.

The stick will wait.

© jumpingfish by David Hasan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License